Islington South & Finsbury’s leadership nomination and the self-flagellation tendency


At last night’s nomination meeting of my local CLP a healthy majority of us voted in support of Ed Miliband for Labour Leader. I was pleased with this.

Coming second was Diane Abbott. I found it hard to take seriously the suggestions that she was a principled leftist. I don’t think anyone seriously thought she would make the best leader – perhaps a matter of hearts overruling heads.

Many think this contest is going come down to Labour going for a Miliband, and there’s certainly much going for that view.

Supporters of David Miliband were few in number but fairly vocal and articulate. They propagated the argument that, whilst their man may not have appealed much to most of the assembled members, it was actually important to select a candidate who talked of things that didn’t necessarily please party members.

The logic was that pleasing party members too much = self-indulgent leftism which would not win over the electoral centre ground.

On the flip side, displeasing party members = a sign of responsibility and potential Prime Minister material.

Truly, advocates of such an argument are Labour’s self-flagellation tendency.

This way of thinking is tired and should be abandoned. There is no inevitable contradiction between being able to enthuse party members during a selection campaign and then going on to win a parliamentary majority after a general election.

We should be looking for a leader with widespread appeal who is able to build alliances with others. Political positioning disliked by lots of party members is not the strategy of a ‘broad church’ candidate. It should not be spun as some sort of brave demonstration of leadership quality.

I want someone to lead us who puts a bit more effort into unifying the party and is less tarred by the divisions of the past few years.

Also: Chris Bryant MP randomly turned up to speak in favour of David Miliband but was turned away as he was not a CLP member and none of the other candidates had guest speakers putting the case for them. A bizarre and amusing occurence, though I’m not sure he appreciated his wasted journey to the Holloway Road when there was so much Gove-baiting to be done in the Commons!


Tags: ,

One Response to “Islington South & Finsbury’s leadership nomination and the self-flagellation tendency”

  1. Pedrito el Bandito Says:

    That’s a shame Bryant wasn’t allowed it. I mean, it’s not a shame that local party democracy wasn’t allowed to be trampled on by yet another snooty and aloof “Listen to me! I must know what’s best because fools once put faith in me!” parliamentary goon. Rather, it’s a shame that the good folk of Islington didn’t get to listen to his no doubt keenly crafted benediction of our messiah, which, I’m told, was scheduled to go something like this:

    “Hello, my name’s Chris Bryant and I believe in freedom, liberty, equality, social justice and lots of other equally detailed things. Oh, human rights – definitely human rights. I could expand upon these deeply-held beliefs of mine if you’d like, except, well, nobody has ever bothered ask that I do before, because, er, platitudes have tended to suffice throughout most of my political career. Is that ok? By the way, I want David Miliband to become leader because I know he’ll promote me and I won’t have to spend much time back in my constituency with all those God awful Welsh people that I have so much in common with.”

    No, let there be no doubt: that invertebrate Bryant’s backing should be reason enough for any rational thinker to cast Miliband the Elder straight to the bottom of their ballot paper. Each co-conspirator is not only shockingly vaccuous, completely devoid of even a trace of smoldering embers in their bellies, but they also exude the kind of sickening “born to rule” arrogance that would make them perfectly at home in the Tory party. Nae clue, nae chat, nae banter; nae chance!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: